How to check if ChatGPT recommends your SaaS (and what to do if it doesn’t)
Your buyers ask AI for “the best tool for…” and get a short list of names. Here’s how to find out, in about 30 minutes, whether yours is one of them.
Search used to give buyers ten blue links and let them decide. An AI assistant gives them three to five names and a reason for each. If you’re not on that list, you don’t lose a ranking position. You lose the chance to be considered at all, and nothing in your analytics tells you it happened.
The good news: checking is simple. You don’t need a tool to do the first pass. You need the right questions and a careful way of reading the answers.
1. Write the questions your buyers actually ask
The most common mistake is asking about your own brand. “What is [YourProduct]?” tells you whether AI knows you exist. It doesn’t tell you whether it recommends you. Buyers who already know your name aren’t the ones you’re losing.
Instead, write down the category a buyer would type. Be specific: “LinkedIn post scheduler”, not “marketing tool”; “invoicing app for freelancers”, not “fintech”. Then turn it into 8–10 questions, in the shapes people really use:
- Best-of: “What’s the best LinkedIn post scheduler?”
- For-whom: “Recommend a LinkedIn scheduler for a two-person agency.”
- Constraint: “Which LinkedIn scheduler is best value under $20 a month?”
- Alternatives: “What are good alternatives to [the market leader]?”
- Comparison: “[Competitor A] vs [Competitor B] for a small team?”
The alternatives question matters most for smaller products. It’s often the only question where AI goes beyond the two or three biggest names.
2. Ask each assistant, the way a buyer would
Ask each question in ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity. A few rules keep the results honest:
- Turn web search on where there’s a choice. That’s how most people use these tools for buying decisions, and it changes which products get named.
- Use a fresh, logged-out or temporary chat. Your own history, past questions about your product and memory settings can tilt the answer towards you.
- Ask each question more than once. AI answers vary between runs. One answer is an anecdote; the pattern across several is the signal.
3. Record three things for every answer
Make a simple sheet with one row per answer and three columns:
- Which products were named, in order. Position matters: being fourth in a long list is very different from being first.
- Whether you were named, and where.
- Which sources were cited. Most assistants with search show the pages they used. Write down the domains.
That third column is the one most founders skip, and it’s the most useful. It tells you why the answer looks the way it does.
4. Read the results
After 20–30 answers you’ll usually see one of four patterns:
- You’re named often and early. Good. Watch it monthly; competitors can overtake you quietly.
- You’re named, but late. AI knows you but doesn’t see you as a default choice. This usually comes down to how often third-party pages mention you next to the leaders.
- You only appear in “alternatives” answers. You’re seen as a challenger. Comparison content and reviews can move you into the main answers.
- You’re never named. The most common result for young products, and the most fixable. AI is working from sources that don’t include you yet.
5. What to do if AI doesn’t recommend you
Look at the sources column. In most niches a handful of domains show up again and again: a couple of “best tools” articles, one or two community threads, a review site. Those pages shape the answer more than your own homepage does.
From there, the work is concrete:
- Make sure your homepage says plainly what you are and who it’s for, in the same words a buyer would use. Clever taglines don’t help a model categorise you.
- Publish honest comparison and alternatives pages for the products AI keeps naming.
- Ask the authors of the articles AI cites most to consider including you, with a clear reason why.
- Take part in the community threads AI reads, as a founder answering questions, not as an ad.
We go deeper on sources in Why AI recommends your competitors, and on a time-boxed plan in A 2-hour plan to get onto AI shortlists.
Free tools that help. Several companies now offer a free quick check, including Ahrefs’ AI visibility checker and HubSpot’s AEO grader. They’re useful for a first look. The manual method above is still worth doing once: reading the full answers teaches you more than any score.
Or let us run it for you
Shortlist Index asks the buyer questions for your niche on ChatGPT and Gemini, with web search on, and shows who gets named, where, and which sources the answers came from. It’s free, takes about two minutes, and needs nothing but your website.